Colorado sued over social media warnings for minors

Colorado sued over social media warnings for minors

An internet trade group filed a lawsuit against Colorado Thursday morning, challenging a new law that would require social media platforms to regularly send pop-up notifications to minors using their sites.

NetChoice argued this is a government attack on free speech and asked the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado to declare the bill unlawful.

Paul Taske, co-director of the NetChoice Litigation Center, spoke with The Center Square in an exclusive interview regarding NetChoice v. Weiser. The litigation center is part of the NetChoice trade association.

“The government has no role in forcing social media to speak on its behalf,” he said. “The government is, of course, free to take whatever positions and share whatever resources it thinks is important … but the government has to speak for itself. It can’t compel private actors to do it.”

Taske added that NetChoice is “extremely confident” that the court will side with it and strike down the law.

The bill in question, House Bill 24-1136, was first passed in 2024 and is set to take effect Jan. 1, 2026.

In addition to requiring the Colorado Department of Education to maintain educational materials on the health effects of social media, it would also require social media platforms to display a pop-up notification every 30 minutes to any user:

• Who is under 18.

• Has been on the platform for one cumulative hour during a 24-hour period.

• Is on the platform between the hours of 10 p.m. and 6 a.m.

Taske said NetChoice, which represents some of the major social media companies like X, YouTube and Meta, does not believe the government should have the ability to force private businesses to speak.

“The First Amendment protects free speech, free expression and free thought. Colorado’s law violates all three of those issues. NetChoice is always going to be fighting back against these sorts of overreaches to protect the principles of free speech online and a vibrant internet,” he said. “As I’ve said, the government is free to espouse whatever view it wants. The problem under this law is that the government can’t compel others to speak for it.”

Designed to encourage “healthier social media use” in Colorado’s youth, the bill received bipartisan support.

“This bill works to give parents and teens the resources they need to make informed decisions about excessive social media usage, especially the dreaded ‘doom scroll,’” said bill sponsor Rep. Judy Amabile, D-Boulder. “We’re working to encourage healthier social media habits among our youth by giving them the tools they need to make smart decisions about their own social media usage and prompting our kids to take a break from their phones.”

Krista Chavez, NetChoice’s senior communications manager, told The Center Square that NetChoice does not believe the bill will actually be effective in addressing those issues.

“Child safety … is a really important thing online, but violating the First Amendment does not protect online safety,” she said.

In the past few years, Colorado has been at the forefront of the social media debate, passing a number of different bills that would regulate its usage. Following Colorado’s passage of HB 24-1136, Minnesota and New York took up similar legislation this year.

Taske said NetChoice hopes the lawsuit will deter other states from moving forward with similar legislation.

“We are always going to be engaged with the state legislatures, and we hope that this lawsuit will demonstrate to other states why these laws are a bad idea,” he said.

Recent data from the Pew Research Center found that nearly half of teens say they are online almost constantly, up from 24% a decade ago. This comes as 41 states are suing Meta for allegedly using addictive features in its platforms, leading many states to consider passing laws addressing social media.

“As lawmakers explore potential regulations, our 2023 survey found a majority of Americans support time limits for minors on social media,” stated the Pew report.

NetChoice argued parents should be the ones receiving controlling social media usage, not the government mandating private companies do so.

“Rather than compelling covered websites to display warning notifications, the Colorado government could have provided more information and education to parents about the same information,” the lawsuit stated. “Parents have a wealth of choices to help oversee their minor children online.”

In 2024, NetChoice won a lawsuit that made it all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. In that case, the justices ruled that there is no social media exception to the First Amendment.

Taske said every American should be concerned about Colorado’s “speech mandates” and the precedent they could set.

“Every American should care about compelled speech, or whether the government can force you to act as a mouthpiece for what it thinks is the correct message on any given topic,” he said. “Today it is social media, but, in the past, it’s been patriotism, it’s been issues of religion, and those issues are consistently relevant to all Americans.”

Events

No events

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

Meeting-Briefs

L-W School Board June 26 Meeting Briefs

Special Education District Update: The fence installation around the playground at Lincoln Way Area Special Education District 843 has been completed except for one gate section that will allow equipment...
Joliet-Junior-college.-Graphic-Logo.2

JJC Embarks on New 10-15 Year Facilities Master Plan Process

Joliet Junior College is laying the groundwork for its physical future, officially launching a comprehensive process to create a new facilities master plan that will guide campus development for the...
Meeting-Briefs

Meeting Summary: Joliet Junior College Board of Trustees for June 25, 2025

The Joliet Junior College Board of Trustees met on Wednesday, June 25, 2025. Key actions included the approval of the fiscal year 2026 budget after a contentious debate and hearing...
Will-County-Board-Meeting-June-18-2025

Will County Board Halts Transportation Plan After Contentious 143rd Street Debate

The Will County Board voted Wednesday to send its five-year, multi-million dollar transportation improvement plan back to committee, effectively pausing all projects after a lengthy and heated debate over the...
Will-County-Board-Meeting-June-18-2025

Will County Board Upholds Zoning Denials, Rejecting Developer Appeals

The Will County Board on Wednesday backed its Planning and Zoning Commission (PZC), denying two separate appeals from property owners who sought to overturn the commission’s recommendations against their projects....
Will-County-Board-Meeting-June-18-2025

Split Vote Halts Monee Truck Terminal Project

A proposed truck terminal on vacant land at West Monee-Manhattan Road in Monee Township was stopped in its tracks Wednesday after the Will County Board delivered a split decision on...
Will-County-Board-Meeting-June-18-2025

Future Quarry Fight Looms as Board Approves ‘Tequila Barrel’ Retreat

While the Will County Board greenlit a unique tourist destination featuring overnight stays in repurposed tequila barrels, it also received formal notice of a coming fight to shut down a...
Meeting-Briefs

News Briefs from the Will County Board June 18 Meeting

Monee Church Designated Historic LandmarkThe Will County Board unanimously voted to designate St. Paul's United Church of Christ in Monee as a historical landmark. Member Judy Ogalla, a Monee native,...
Frankfort-Village-Board-Meeting-Graphic-June-16-2025

Frankfort Approves Outdoor Patios for The Loft and Grounded Coffee Bar, Waives All Parking Requirements

Downtown Frankfort is set to expand its outdoor dining options after the Village Board on Monday approved plans for new patios at two adjacent businesses, The Loft and Grounded Coffee...
Frankfort-Village-Board-Meeting-Graphic-June-16-2025

Frankfort Police Department to Get Four New Vehicles in Fleet Upgrade

FRANKFORT, Ill. – The Frankfort Police Department will be updating its aging fleet after the Village Board approved the purchase of four new vehicles for a total cost not to...
Frankfort-Village-Board-Meeting-Graphic-June-16-2025

Indoor Pickleball Facility ‘Pickled!’ Gets Green Light in Frankfort

A new indoor pickleball facility named "Pickled!" is set to open in Frankfort after the Village Board granted a special use permit for the business at its Monday meeting. The...
Frankfort-Village-Board-Meeting-Graphic-June-16-2025

Frankfort to Install Public Wi-Fi at Breidert Green

Visitors to Breidert Green in downtown Frankfort will soon have access to free public wireless internet. The Village Board on Monday approved the purchase and installation of Wi-Fi equipment to...
Frankfort-Village-Board-Meeting-Graphic-June-16-2025

Frankfort Board Approves Indoor Recreation Facility and Setback Variance

The Frankfort Village Board gave its approval to two separate development projects Monday night, clearing the way for a new indoor pickleball facility and a residential addition. Trustees unanimously granted...
Frankfort-Village-Board-Meeting-Graphic-June-16-2025

Meeting Briefs: Frankfort Village Board for June 16, 2025

Downtown Patios Approved, Parking Waived: The Village Board approved outdoor seating for The Loft and Grounded Coffee Bar on Ash Street. To support the downtown businesses, trustees also voted to waive...
Will-County-Executive-Committee-Meeting-June-12-2025

Mental Health Board Awards $5 Million in Grants to Will County Organizations

The Will County Community Mental Health Board has distributed over $5 million in grants to 39 local organizations, marking the completion of its inaugural funding cycle since voters approved the...